Traditional Punishment & ADHD
A Toxic Force for Neurodivergent Minds and a Warning Bell for the Education System

Dr Hassan Farhangi
The transition to secondary school is inherently daunting. However, for a child navigating the neurological differences of ADHD, this transition can become an exhausting ordeal. Our recent experience over the past two months—witnessing over 15 detentions imposed on our 11-year-old son—is not a reflection of misbehaviour, but rather a testament to the educational system’s failure to understand the neurobiological reality of these children.
When discussing this with SEN (Special Educational Needs) coordinators and school leaders, I was met with a wall of rigid, traditional disciplinary methods—cookie-cutter punitive approaches that staff default to because it is all they know, stubbornly attempting to force every child into the same mould through the hammer of punishment and control.
The Disaster of Traditional Punishment for Students with ADHD
Traditional disciplinary systems in UK schools—such as continuous detentions, threats, shouting, and isolation—are built upon a flawed premise: that a child with ADHD is willfully defiant and will correct their behaviour if punished severely enough. Yet neuroscience screams that this assumption is entirely false.
-
Triggering the Cycle of Stress and Tics: Repeated punishments and psychological pressures keep the nervous system of these children in a constant state of “fight or flight.” The result is acute anxiety, emotional burnout, and the exacerbation of physical tics that trap the child in a cycle of helplessness.
-
Labelling and Criminalising Disability: When an educator or pastoral staff member interprets impulsivity, interrupting, or involuntary responses caused by attention deficits as a “deliberate behavioural pattern,” they are essentially criminalising a neurological difference. Such labelling shatters a child’s self-esteem.
-
Breaking Confidence Instead of Building Discipline: Traditional punishment does not teach a child how to regulate their emotions; instead, it teaches them that a coercive power structure rules over them and that they are “losers.”
A School That Resembles a Prison
Today, many UK schools have tragically transformed from sanctuaries for discovering potential into “petty correctional facilities for behavioral control.” Out of insufficient training or occupational burnout, teachers and educators have retreated to crude, aggressive linguistic and disciplinary tools:
-
Shouting and Intimidation: Relying on intimidation rather than dialogue and problem-solving to enforce dead silence in the classroom.
-
Mechanical Detentions: Confining students after school hours without accounting for how the severe exhaustion of an ADHD brain makes it impossible to endure such grinding punishments.
-
Isolation: Exiling children with behavioural challenges to isolation booths under the guise of maintaining classroom order.
These instruments turn the school from a place of “passion for learning” into a daily battlefield between the system and vulnerable children.
The Reflection of This Failure in Future Generations
The consequences of this flawed, rigid educational system are vividly visible across society: a young generation stripped of their vitality, rising rates of depression among adolescents, and adults carrying the psychological trauma of their school years. Studies show that the risks associated with untreated ADHD are high, and punitive schools—through isolation and alienation—only double those dangers.
The Time Has Come to Launch a Campaign for Change
We can no longer remain silent or surrender to administrators hiding behind rigid bureaucratic guidelines. The time has come to spark a movement and an awareness campaign to reform the training and mindset of educators in schools.
As parents, psychologists, and conscious mentors, we must loudly champion the following demands:
-
Mandatory Neurodiversity Training for Teachers: No educator should be allowed into a classroom without a thorough understanding of ADHD and autism.
-
Abolishing Outdated Punitive Measures: Detentions and isolation booths must be stripped from the educational framework and replaced with supportive approaches grounded in emotional regulation.
-
Shifting from “Control” to “Inspiring Passion”: Schools must be spaces for cultivating creativity rather than detention camps designed to suppress differences.
Our children deserve an environment supported by empathy, understanding, and scientific standards rather than systematic punishment. Fighting to alter this routine is not only defending our own child, but defending the very humanity of education.



